You seem to be harping on which expansion they 'include' it with. That's not the point. I don't really give a smurf which expansion it should be with. Put it in ToAU for all I care. I just think it should be free, because we are already paying $14 a month for this game and in the past $20 has bought you a wide variety of new content like new jobs, areas, endgame events, and storylines all in one. Abyssea (and the scenarios) are now $30 for what is quite obviously a whole lot less.