Hmm... for me it would be either VIII or X. Although IX is in the running too O_O;; Oh GOD <_<

VIII reason being because I loved it all... Love triangle... sorceresses... Squall... I know its a poor excuse, but so what ^~.

X was pretty cool. Layers to the story... Main male has a father issue... Main female has to save the world even though she accepts she may die in doing so...

IX was fantastic - just like you said reinward, it was so charming and magical... Kawaii! =^^=