I was pretty good at Soul Calibur 2, but I haven't put in the same committment to 3 and 4, though I still like to think I can handle myself well enough with them too. Also, SC2 was just much easier. All the characters had relatively simpler inputs and mix-ups back then compared to now (Ivy is much harder to master, ditto Raphael and Talim). You could quite easily justify the idea that a lot more people were really good at SC2 than 3 and 4, so it's not really a big achievement. But I loved the game. I've had interest in other fighters, but the only other one I'd consider myself better than average at is Tekken.

As a bit of an arcade junkie back in those high school years, I was also decent at DDR, Pump It Up! and Drum Mania. Not spectucularly good, but good enough to get crowds standing around watching me (keep in mind that this was when these games were new and still somewhat cool xD). I also played a lot of Initial D ver. 3, but still about 8-10 seconds off the world record times posted online on every track. I could beat the average player quite easily though.

I'm awful at FPS, RTS, simulation racing and action hack-and-slash, which is a shame because I quite like some of the games each of those genre offers.