I am hiding behind the fourth wall

Persephone probably thought it would be worse for her if she claimed, and she gave up

Err, sure

I hope not

I thought of this for a second as well...

That sounds like something from I want it that way :o

Idk, I don't have a read on him... unless he's a cylon

Queen, easily

A second scum faction would be more of a mindsmurf, I think, but what if the mindsmurf of this mafia game is just us thinking it's a mindsmurf, and it's actually a fairly simple setup, so we overthink it and get mindsmurfed!? Nah, probably not... It can't be a paranoid gun owner, though, because night 1 people with no night action died.