Mindsmurf Mafia - GAME OVER - Town Win - The Triple H gods are the heroes!

[[M] Kurt - Cool Dad]

I still don't know what to do or say, so I'll just give my probably useless opinion on things that seem to be an issue.

People bandwaggoning on Medusa: Really, I don't think this is a sign of scum, not here anyway. It just seemed 3 people after Hygieia wanted to joke vote and everyone went for Medusa.

Everything to do with Dionysus: This seems to be the only thing so far that is actually scummy at all. Hestia gives some advice, Dionysus claims he is a new player, Hera questions Hestia, Tyche defends Hestia, Hestia makes a slightly cryptic post, and ends with something about how hopefully Medusa is Mafia.

I say Medusa. Smurfer has snakes for hair.

WAIT! Zeus is SMURFING with us. Medusa's probably the doctor.

I'm going to say Asclepius. It'd be just like Zeus to make the God of Medicine a serial killer or something.

##Vote: Asclepius

WAIT! Zeus is SMURFING with us. Medusa's probably the doctor.

Any reasoning for this? No, didn't think so. Also, if there was a reason you don't call out the doctor. With that said, I can make a bet you are new and unaware that you don't just make random uneducated claims. Don't let it happen again bub

This early in the game and the fact that Dionysus has clearly been hitting the sauce already, I don't think anyone is going to legitimize that roleclaim... er, roleblame? I like that, roleblame.

Looking through Day 0 there's not much to get from, so I'll just post my thoughts on the only post that stuck out.

WAIT! Zeus is SMURFING with us. Medusa's probably the doctor.

Any reasoning for this? No, didn't think so. Also, if there was a reason you don't call out the doctor. With that said, I can make a bet you are new and unaware that you don't just make random uneducated claims. Don't let it happen again bub

Whenever I see these "don't call out the cop/doctor" posts I feel like someone is trying too hard to look like town. Especially when no one's asking anything of a potential cop/doctor.

More interesting things usually happen on Day one, so I'm sure I'll see something worth placing a more definite vote on later. For now Hestia is just a tiny iota more suspicious than the rest of the bunch to me.

I wouldn't necessarily say suspicious. Some people just take mafia more seriously than others. Still, they're pointing fingers and so are you.

And now so am I, damn ;_;

Looking through Day 0 there's not much to get from, so I'll just post my thoughts on the only post that stuck out.

WAIT! Zeus is SMURFING with us. Medusa's probably the doctor.

Any reasoning for this? No, didn't think so. Also, if there was a reason you don't call out the doctor. With that said, I can make a bet you are new and unaware that you don't just make random uneducated claims. Don't let it happen again bub

Whenever I see these "don't call out the cop/doctor" posts I feel like someone is trying too hard to look like town. Especially when no one's asking anything of a potential cop/doctor.

More interesting things usually happen on Day one, so I'm sure I'll see something worth placing a more definite vote on later. For now Hestia is just a tiny iota more suspicious than the rest of the bunch to me.

You can interpret however you choose, either I'm giving advice to try and help beginners sort out how to play messy mafia or I'm just trying to look town. I can't sway how you interpret actions. However, calling out a Doctor or Cop early in the game is always bad/scummy play. Not much has really happened yet. With any luck Medusa is mafia and we delayed her a day from finding out who her buddies are!

Like I said, I don't think anyone would really legitimize any type of role claim/blame this early in the game. But why, then are you subtly accusing Medusa of being mafia? Not especially cautious, though you admonish others for the lack thereof. Interesting.

Also, Persephone, it can be our place. Wouldn't you like to be the dread queen of the underworld?

I looked through the thread and don't have any strong suspicions yet. The only thing I saw that caught my eye was Hestia's defensive response here:

Whenever I see these "don't call out the cop/doctor" posts I feel like someone is trying too hard to look like town. Especially when no one's asking anything of a potential cop/doctor.

More interesting things usually happen on Day one, so I'm sure I'll see something worth placing a more definite vote on later. For now Hestia is just a tiny iota more suspicious than the rest of the bunch to me.

You can interpret however you choose, either I'm giving advice to try and help beginners sort out how to play messy mafia or I'm just trying to look town. I can't sway how you interpret actions. However, calling out a Doctor or Cop early in the game is always bad/scummy play. Not much has really happened yet. With any luck Medusa is mafia and we delayed her a day from finding out who her buddies are!

This post struck me as quick to be defensive. Though I still wasn't very suspicious until the last sentence, when she tried to distract and point to someone else as potentially mafia and emphasize how good it would be for the town.

It's not much at all at this point on the game, but it's the only thing that remotely stood out for me (except for Cerebrus's distaste for Boston, and if that's not scummy I don't know what is). But I might not be around until after the day ends tomorrow, so I'll leave this vote for now:

##Vote: Hestia

I don't really know what else to add here. Hestia seemed to be a little bit cryptic to me, and she seemed to be trying to defend herself without making it look like she was defending herself. I will hopefully be here for the rest of the day, so I won't make my vote yet, but if I had to vote right now, it would be for Hestia.