I looked through the thread and don't have any strong suspicions yet. The only thing I saw that caught my eye was Hestia's defensive response here:

Quote Originally Posted by [M] Hestia View Post
Quote Originally Posted by [M] Hera View Post
Whenever I see these "don't call out the cop/doctor" posts I feel like someone is trying too hard to look like town. Especially when no one's asking anything of a potential cop/doctor.

More interesting things usually happen on Day one, so I'm sure I'll see something worth placing a more definite vote on later. For now Hestia is just a tiny iota more suspicious than the rest of the bunch to me.
You can interpret however you choose, either I'm giving advice to try and help beginners sort out how to play messy mafia or I'm just trying to look town. I can't sway how you interpret actions. However, calling out a Doctor or Cop early in the game is always bad/scummy play. Not much has really happened yet. With any luck Medusa is mafia and we delayed her a day from finding out who her buddies are!
This post struck me as quick to be defensive. Though I still wasn't very suspicious until the last sentence, when she tried to distract and point to someone else as potentially mafia and emphasize how good it would be for the town.

It's not much at all at this point on the game, but it's the only thing that remotely stood out for me (except for Cerebrus's distaste for Boston, and if that's not scummy I don't know what is). But I might not be around until after the day ends tomorrow, so I'll leave this vote for now:

##Vote: Hestia