Tyche has holes in his story...

He was recruited night 3, but day 3 Hygeia defended him

When you are recruited, you would be told by pm at the start of the day

I once again think he was just doing research to make a "strong" claim.

And Hestia, where did Nyx claim? Or are you talking about me? I have confirmed myself as a vig. That doesn't mean you'll believe me, but I "protected" Athena, Eros, Artemis, Aphrodite twice, then Dionysus. Everyone I "protected" died, except for the 2 nights where the black hole was in effect. That means I have to be a vig. The chance of there still being 2 killing roles with both serial killers down and someone choosing to kill my target every night and my protection failing is WAAAY too impossible.