No, it wasn't. It was ropy (Which I can forgive because there's a lot of development to go), it felt completely hollow, and it was lacking in impact. Getting shot seemed like a balled up piece of paper hitting you in the side of the head. Knocking that guy off the edge 'felt' like hitting a twig with another twig. I mean, if other people enjoy it, I won't hold it against them, but after the mediocrity that was BioShock I'll be content to read the story somewhere else and watch a few cutscenes online.