Which Game to Buy

[JKTrix]

But Bayonetta isn't.

+1 for that.

[Slothy]

Infamous is massively overrated in my book.

I have to agree to be honest. I enjoyed the game but it was filled with it's share of issues. Not the least of which being that it was far too repetitive, had a difficulty that was all over the place at times and was pretty lacking in interesting side missions or things to do in the city in general. The core game had a lot of potential, enough for me to look forward to the sequel, but it had lot's of rough edges.

[Kenshin IV]

Wow, that's a ton of options you got there. So I'm just going to give you some opinions on each game you've mentioned.

Console Must Haves:

Uncharted 2
Batman: Arkham Asylum
Dead Space
Bayonetta

DLC Must Haves:

Braid
Scott Pilgrim
Castle Crashers

Good to very good games that are not must owns:

Infamous
ModNation Racers

Games you could live without:

Final Fantasy XIII
Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2 (it doesn't compare to the original Ninja Gaiden in any way, shape, or form)
God of War Collection (there's no reason to own it if you have the first two)
Modern Warfare 2 (COD4 is much cheaper and MUCH better)
Killzone 2

As for a Wii game, wait for Epic Mickey, Donkey Kong Country, or Kirby. Unless you don't own either of the Mario Galaxy's or New Super Mario Bros. yet.

[Depression Moon]

Decided to get Scott Pilgrim since that was the cheapest route and I didn't hear word from my lil brother's friend.

[Mo-Nercy]

I'm too late, but Bayonetta is awesome. Do try and pick it up in the future.

And depending on how far into puberty your little brother is, chances are he'll smurfing love the game.

[Bolivar]

Well like we said if you go for the PS2, the new slims are less than $100 so you better talk him down.