
Originally Posted by
Elpizo
I happen to like TA's laws and dispatch missions. I liked everything about TA, and all I liked was stripped away in TA2.
Good story? TA2 didn't have one. The thrown together mess that tells you nothing doesn't count as a story. Few characters were developed or fleshed out at all, some were just there. Adelle probably was the most interesting, and even she was handled so badly it ain't even funny.
Laws? A useless optional thing, and more often than not you end up breaking them anyway because you don't care. The laws in TA were great. They represented the unfairness of Ivalice's system, with the queen and prince having absolute control over the laws. Every time that judge gave you a card, you knew you could blame Remedi and Mewt for your troubles. Laws in TA were both a gameplay thing as a political story thing. In TA2, they were dumb. And I know nobody will agree with me.
Music? Few new tracks. Most recycled from TA or FF XII. If I wanted to hear that music, I'd play those (better) games.
Only thing TA2 improved upon was probably graphics, and more balanced classes. The addition of slopes made battlefields more realistic and pleasant to the eye. At the same time, I disliked the big influence XII had on this game. The bazaar, ultimate weapon (Tournesol) were all ripped right out of XII. Same with the Espers. What's the difference between Espers and summons? Prettier animation. In TA, they were Totema, and totally different entities all together. In TA2, they were summons, had no story purpose whatsoever and basically, were just there. Kind of like everything in the game.
It's passable to play, but the entire game screams mediocre, unlike FFTA (my first FF game, so I guess I'm biased) which I consider a little underrated masterpiece. I see it as a mistake to set TA2 in XII's Ivalice, it makes it more a (bad) XII-sequel than a TA sequel. People complained FFTA was kiddy compared to FFT. Well, in that case, FFTA2 was for toddlers.
I know everybody's going to disagree with me anyway, so if you're going to bring out the big guns to say I'm wrong and you're right and that TA's laws sucked and the stuff, please don't. It won't get either of us anywhere, since I'm not going to change my opinion. Let's just leave it at this. I know why people think TA2 > TA, and I can see where they're coming from, but I don't agree with it. At all. That's all there is to it.