I'm just gonna pick willy nilly and see how right I get. Yay, randomness!

Also, I already won Best Newbie, so Naomi deserves it.

(SPOILER)
1. Best Member
Guardian XIII

2. Best Male
Rantzien

3. Best Female
Shorty

4. Best Admin
Rantzien

5. Best Cid's Knight
fire_of_avalon

6. Best Site Staff
Baloki

7. Best Recognized Member/Former Staff
Raistlin

8. Best Veteran
Guardian XIII

9. Best Regular
Guardian XIII

10. Best Newbie
Naomi The Insane

11. Nicest Member
Guardian XIII

12. Evilest Member
Bunny

13. Sexiest/Cutest Male
Blues Agent's Package

14. Sexiest/Cutest Female
Zeldy

15. Best Custom Rank
Peegee

16. Best Avatar
Clo

17. Best Signature
Rantzien

18. Best Artist
Sagensyg

19. Best Writer
Guardian XIII

20. Best Poster
I'm my own MILF

21. Best Spammer
Peegee

22. Best Chatter
Melissaur

23. Best Visitor Messager
Christmas

24. Best Blogger
Yeargdribble

25. Best Thread
The EoFF Beard Contest

26. Best Post
\Halo Reach: Heroes in a half-shell, TURTLE GOD DAMN POWER!

27. Funniest Member
Psychotic

28. Weirdest Member
Peegee

29. Best Returning Member
Alive-Man

30. Most Powerful Member
fire_of_avalon

31. Most Informative Member
Raistlin

32. Most Productive Member
Rantzien

33. Most Underrated Member
Miriel

34. Most Improved Member
Sir Lancealot

35. Most Missed Member
RSL

36. Most Hardcore Gamer
Roto13

37. Most Helpful Gamer
Jessweeee♪

38. Most Helpful Techy
Rantzien

39. Most Helpful Member
Rantzien

40. Cutest Couple
Del Murder & Miriel

Most Likely To…

41. Become a Cid's Knight
Guardian XIII

42. Get Banned
Hypoallergenic Cactuar

43. Win a Ciddie for the very first time
Naomi The Insane

44. Not realize the switch to vB4
Cid

45. Grow a massive beard
Jiro

46. Successfully hijack Santa's sleigh
Psychotic

47. Be on the Naughty List
NorthernChaosGod

48. Be a Honey Bee Girl
NorthernChaosGod

49. Be a Bad SeeD
Raistlin

50. Get Together
Peegee & Raistlin