I found it quite bizzare he ALREADY knew it was one of us, without any one of us investigating outside possobilies. Of course the captain would never try to lead us astray, I just think he's batinsane. What are the chances, given the complete lack of evidence, that one of our reapers or substitute reapers who have shown themselves nothing but loyal to us, is ACTUALLY going to turn on us?
Of course, there is a chance that probability will once again go into a back ally to service Drama as would a copper piece Harlot.