Beat it, enjoyed it. It was something different from anything else I've played, and it was fun trying to piece things together and dig about for an answer.

As Mo says, the city is huge but so empty at the same time. It always feels like you're driving down the same street. Would've liked more personality. Los Santos in GTA: SA was a more interesting representation of LA, I think.

Story was both intriguing and confusing. I feel the need to listen to Dead Man's Gun though.

I don't think you can fairly compare it to Red Dead and GTA, because it's simply not a sandbox game. Sure, there's an open world to drive about in, but it definitely is not a sandbox. A good game, a fun experience. It just felt like it lacked a little, I don't know, something to make it an all time classic.