P4 - Mafia XIX Game Thread - [Game Over] Mafia DOMINATION

[[M] Elize]

Naoto, this isn't good enough.

Sorry about not being around, I was dealing with some fatigue.

To clarify why I did not participate in the tie breaker when given the chance was simply a matter of of not believing either was truly guilty. Both suspects were trying too hard to stand out and put targets on their backs. I'm not the type to join in capital punishment against a suspect unless I know all the facts point to a guaranteed guilty verdict.

As I was suggesting earlier, I would be more concerned about those who are trying to stay below the radar. Considering how quick everyone was to lynch the obvious odd balls in the town, it would seem to me that the best course of action for the mafia members would be to mostly keep low profiles and try to avoid any kind of open suspicion, hence my suspicion of Chie, Yukiko, Namatame, and Hanako. I would also be somewhat suspicious of Souji, since he quickly came in, mentioned his "experience", jumped onto getting rid of Teddie rather quickly rather than be reluctant like most of the townsfolk were. It felt to me like they were creating a sense of rep for themselves, to get the rest of us to trust them. He quickly chooses a target and then quickly tries to steer everyone towards someone who is, sadly in hindsight, too obvious to be part of the mafia. In an effort to mislead us.

It just feels to me like Souji was trying to choose a target to get everyone frenzied over to cover their own tracks, while people really discuss things to see if anyone left more subtle clues. While this is certainly damning for myself as well, I feel the best way to hide would be to try an act like the authority and instigator.

While I think many of your points are fine and dandy, refusing to vote because we have no evidence is exactly what you must do cause of one simple reason: we have no evidence! If you mean to say you will never vote until we lynch at least one scum then I'm at a loss about your goals.

I was hoping to discuss Souji more in detail but I'm going for Shu for now since I don't suspect Rise.

##VOTE: [M] Shu

I now understand why your students gave you that nickname...

You fail to remember the record Moroorka, I did vote. I voted for Shu because I felt he was the most guilty. Jumping onto the bandwagon of a mob with shaky evidence would have just made me an accomplice to the death of an innocent, at the same time, by the time I had a chance to read through all the records and cast a vote, there was only an hour left to make a choice which is not enough time to convince people to change their vote, especially when so few are active in my time zone.

For now, I do vote for Shu
##VOTE: [M] Shu as I feel he hasn't justified much of a reason to not be suspicious. Casting the final vote doesn't make Rise guilty, for now, and I'm more concerned about the people in the background than the ones who are putting targets on their backs.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Well, I've read through most of today and I think I'm about up to speed. Though it seems like it's between Rise and Shu today, I'm going to place my vote on Mitsuo. He's still the one I find most suspicious and, maybe I'm wrong, but I don't have a strong enough feeling that Shu or Rise are Mafia to vote on them today.

##Vote: [M] Mitsuo

Also, how long do we have left for today?

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

I now understand why your students gave you that nickname...

You fail to remember the record Moroorka, I did vote. I voted for Shu because I felt he was the most guilty. Jumping onto the bandwagon of a mob with shaky evidence would have just made me an accomplice to the death of an innocent, at the same time, by the time I had a chance to read through all the records and cast a vote, there was only an hour left to make a choice which is not enough time to convince people to change their vote, especially when so few are active in my time zone.

For now, I do vote for Shu
##VOTE: [M] Shu as I feel he hasn't justified much of a reason to not be suspicious. Casting the final vote doesn't make Rise guilty, for now, and I'm more concerned about the people in the background than the ones who are putting targets on their backs.

Is that the case against her? I'll have to go reread some stuff, I missed that. I hardly think that's a good reason. Someone had to eventually and Rise just happen to come in at the last hour and everyone decided that she would break the tie.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Also, how long do we have left for today?

It appears that one hour remains.

Current votecount.

[M] Shu (5) - [M] Tanaka, [M] Morooka, [M] Rise, [M] Yukiko, [M] Naoto
[M] Mitsuo (2) - [M] Chie, [M] Namatame
[M] Rise (2) - [M] Shu, [M] Souji
[M] Souji (1) - [M] Kanji
[M] Chie (1) - [M] Adachi

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Looks like Shu is going to be hung Because it seems kinda slow/dead in here at this point in time.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Wow, I thought Rise and Shu were closer in votes, but it seems that Shu is pretty much definitely a goner.

[[M] Felix]

Yet another wasted lynch guys

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

God, this is so hard. Even though I have read what I missed, I can't make a guess. T_T

[[M] Caprica]

See why I didn't want to vote Shu? I'm sure it's a mistake to lynch him, as it is to lynch Rise.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

OOC: What would happen if no one voted for anyone, and then time ran out?

I also hanging Shu is a mistake....

[[M] Mom – Host]

30 minutes remain.

Ah, sweet Nanako. How naive of you, that will never happen, and in the circumstances that it ever does, someone will eventually have to lend their vote to end the day.

[[M] Adama]

smurf. What exactly is everyone's evidence against Shu? He seems like someone to watch, but I'm not entirely sure it's deserve of a lynch. I hope you guys are very confident in your votes.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

##vote: [M] Igor. He called me naive. Just because it hasn't happened doesn't mean it won't...

[[M] Mom – Host]

Well, it appears the votecount will not change, so Day 2 is over...

Prepare yourselves.

[[M] Caprica]

Nanako, just because you are an orphan doesn't mean you can vote for the host. He's immortal.