P4 - Mafia XIX Game Thread - [Game Over] Mafia DOMINATION

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

My thoughts are that all the inactives need to pipe up, and all the actives need to get in on day 3... This is not going well and with everyone in different time zones and having stuff to do it's going slow too. I already put in my vote and for why. I'm glad Namatame showed up, hopefully more people will filter in as well.

[[M] Caprica]

Also here is a summary of the major ideas that have been thrown around.

1) Mafia votes for Mitsuo and Teddie on day 1. Proposed by Morooka, a confirmed Townie. Out of Yukiko, Adachi and Namatame there is a mafia member. Also among Mitsuo, Souji, Nanako, Myself and Rise there is a mafia member. (We now know Shu that is town) He expressed doubt about Mitsuo being mafia.

2) Mafia hiding as inactives. Daidama, Honoka, and Kou are the three least active players. Daisuke and Tanaka are barely active at all. Mitsuo is the first to propose it to my knowledge.

Next up, an overview of the cases for people who have votes on them.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Well, while I still think Mitsuo is most likely to be scum at the moment, I'm more inclined to vote for someone who has been less active, such as Hanako or Daidara. Why? Because so far, the Mafia have targeted people who have been fairly active on the days before they were killed and we have also lynched people who were fairly active, hence why today has had such limited activity. If we keep lynching the active people, and the Mafia keep night-killing the other active people, soon there won't be any activity at all and the Mafia can just swoop in and finish of the less active people.

Of course, this could be risky, if none of the Mafia actually are hiding among the inactives, however with someone who has been as inactive as Hanako, I'm willing to take that risk. At the moment, she's just a hindrance to the town, which is why I'm placing my vote on her for now.

##Vote: [M] Hanako

[[M] Caprica]

I'll x-quote each vote post for the case collecting to make it easier for myself.

The case against Souji. Keep in mind I'm just collecting everything to make it easier to see whats going on.

If it means so much to you Adachi I will vote.

## Vote [M] Souji

My lack of post come from having a busy schedule during what appears to be the "peak hours" of the game. There is usually not much activity in my time zone.

As for not voting for Souji right away, I wished to give him a chance to either defend himself or I was hoping to have him slip up and add some more weight to my position. If you think about it Adachi, he's been acting the same as me, coming in and making big statements then leaving to let everyone make paranoid statements. Shu was certainly a mistake but his actions for the first two days were erratic, which made him suspicious. Teddie on the other hand was obvious off kilter from the rest and was too obvious. Then he jumped to Rise for no reason other than she made the lynching vote despite the timetable showing she had only a small amount of time left of Day 1 to make a guess, which circumstantially is not good enough evidence to make her a target.

I feel he has been trying to control this investigation more than any of us and that just doesn't sit well with me.

I guess that makes a bit more sense, but I still think it's a long shot idea, kinda like Mitsuo's idea about the inactives. Who know though. All we can do is choose and hope to god we do the right thing.

As for me, I'd have to go with Naoto. She's presented the best case against Souji, and his "way to waste a vote" comment strikes me wrong. So for now...
##VOTE: Souji

I guess that makes a bit more sense, but I still think it's a long shot idea, kinda like Mitsuo's idea about the inactives. Who know though. All we can do is choose and hope to god we do the right thing.

As for me, I'd have to go with Naoto. She's presented the best case against Souji, and his "way to waste a vote" comment strikes me wrong. So for now...
##VOTE: Souji

I've been agreeing with Naoto for quite some time and seeing as how Souji did nothing to defend himself at this point...

##Vote [M] Souji

Also, I'm getting kinda sick of being a conscientious non-voter. xDD

[[M] Caprica]

The cases against Daidara, Hanako and Kou. I'm grouping all three together because they each have done about nothing and the same can be said for each of them.

It all makes sense now. The doctor was nightkilled, even though usually a doctor will protect themselves night 1. So the mafia and the second killer both targeted Dojima. His protection stopped one kill, but then the other one got him.

I bet the serial killer is someone who is quiet.

##Vote: Daidara.

Well I don't know about you guys, but I'm gonna prod some inactives.

##Vote: Kou


And none of this "oh I'm just prodding an inactive it's not a serious vote" bull. If it's not a serious vote it's not gonna be taken seriously. It's gonna stay. We don't have to lynch one, but if we're going to put the pressure on, we have to put the pressure on.

Well, while I still think Mitsuo is most likely to be scum at the moment, I'm more inclined to vote for someone who has been less active, such as Hanako or Daidara. Why? Because so far, the Mafia have targeted people who have been fairly active on the days before they were killed and we have also lynched people who were fairly active, hence why today has had such limited activity. If we keep lynching the active people, and the Mafia keep night-killing the other active people, soon there won't be any activity at all and the Mafia can just swoop in and finish of the less active people.

Of course, this could be risky, if none of the Mafia actually are hiding among the inactives, however with someone who has been as inactive as Hanako, I'm willing to take that risk. At the moment, she's just a hindrance to the town, which is why I'm placing my vote on her for now.

##Vote: [M] Hanako

[[M] Caprica]

Finally the case against Naoto.

Naoto's been breezing in, making big posts not saying too much and then breezing out. Voted consistently for Shu; that's not a scum move, but I would like to say good job for consistency.

With her usual vote target gone, you'd think she'd vote for Souji after this post, right?

Yet another wasted lynch guys

Why did you sound so certain Souji? Do you know something the rest of us didn't? Very curious to make that statement before we even knew Shu was innocent.

First you move everyone against Teddie really quickly and now you are trying to pin things on Rise and Mitsuo. For someone who feels we need to be careful, you have certainly been quick to call out people as mafia. I find this very suspicious...

But no vote tacked on the end. I find that a bit suspicious. I mean, it makes sense to vote for who you think is most suspicious, right? I'unno guys.

You're just making me feel off, Naoto. You seem to have this presence, have the appearance of being active, without making a whole lot of posts. 8, so far sweetheart. Just 8 posts.

With that in mind, you're as good as I've got except for Mitsuo. I might be contradicting my earlier statement by not voting for him, who I find most suspicious, but he'll say plenty enough to pull dirt from and you're just a little too quiet for my liking.

##Vote: [M] Naoto

Bit quiet in here guys

[[M] Caprica]

Now that the summary is up people can get a basic feel for the situation and start talking sooner.

Also this irks me a bit.

Well, while I still think Mitsuo is most likely to be scum at the moment, I'm more inclined to vote for someone who has been less active, such as Hanako or Daidara. Why? Because so far, the Mafia have targeted people who have been fairly active on the days before they were killed and we have also lynched people who were fairly active, hence why today has had such limited activity. If we keep lynching the active people, and the Mafia keep night-killing the other active people, soon there won't be any activity at all and the Mafia can just swoop in and finish of the less active people.

Of course, this could be risky, if none of the Mafia actually are hiding among the inactives, however with someone who has been as inactive as Hanako, I'm willing to take that risk. At the moment, she's just a hindrance to the town, which is why I'm placing my vote on her for now.

##Vote: [M] Hanako

If you think Mitsuo is most likely scum, then why are you not voting for him? Like I said, go with what you think.

Keep in mind that I do agree with the fact that the inactives need to start playing. I just find it a bit odd is all.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Now that the summary is up people can get a basic feel for the situation and start talking sooner.

Also this irks me a bit.

Well, while I still think Mitsuo is most likely to be scum at the moment, I'm more inclined to vote for someone who has been less active, such as Hanako or Daidara. Why? Because so far, the Mafia have targeted people who have been fairly active on the days before they were killed and we have also lynched people who were fairly active, hence why today has had such limited activity. If we keep lynching the active people, and the Mafia keep night-killing the other active people, soon there won't be any activity at all and the Mafia can just swoop in and finish of the less active people.

Of course, this could be risky, if none of the Mafia actually are hiding among the inactives, however with someone who has been as inactive as Hanako, I'm willing to take that risk. At the moment, she's just a hindrance to the town, which is why I'm placing my vote on her for now.

##Vote: [M] Hanako

If you think Mitsuo is most likely scum, then why are you not voting for him? Like I said, go with what you think.

Keep in mind that I do agree with the fact that the inactives need to start playing. I just find it a bit odd is all.

I'm gonna bash you in the face! I was just reading up and I thought the same thing. If hes so suspicious of Mitsuo why not vote for him? UNLESS he knows Mitsuo is Mafia... Pretty sketchy~

[[M] Caprica]

Bashing me it the face? We really do think alike Nanako!

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

ok, it looks like my post didn't go through, I tried to post earlier that I wasn't gonna be around for most of today or the next day and so on except weekends because my school blocked EoFF. that sucks. Anyways, I don't have a particular person I'm leaning towards right now, but I'm thinking we need to get an inactive because if we keep lynching active townies.... welll. there wont be any discusion at all. Is there anyone who hasn't posted period?

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

Now that the summary is up people can get a basic feel for the situation and start talking sooner.

Also this irks me a bit.

Well, while I still think Mitsuo is most likely to be scum at the moment, I'm more inclined to vote for someone who has been less active, such as Hanako or Daidara. Why? Because so far, the Mafia have targeted people who have been fairly active on the days before they were killed and we have also lynched people who were fairly active, hence why today has had such limited activity. If we keep lynching the active people, and the Mafia keep night-killing the other active people, soon there won't be any activity at all and the Mafia can just swoop in and finish of the less active people.

Of course, this could be risky, if none of the Mafia actually are hiding among the inactives, however with someone who has been as inactive as Hanako, I'm willing to take that risk. At the moment, she's just a hindrance to the town, which is why I'm placing my vote on her for now.

##Vote: [M] Hanako

If you think Mitsuo is most likely scum, then why are you not voting for him? Like I said, go with what you think.

Keep in mind that I do agree with the fact that the inactives need to start playing. I just find it a bit odd is all.

I'm gonna bash you in the face! I was just reading up and I thought the same thing. If hes so suspicious of Mitsuo why not vote for him? UNLESS he knows Mitsuo is Mafia... Pretty sketchy~

:goomba: No estoy Mafia!

[[M] Caprica]

As I said, everyone posted at least once, but Daidama, Hanako and Kou are the main three that need to start doing something. Hanako hasthe least with 1 post on day 1.

[[M] Aaron]

I'll be switching my vote to Hanako. As I said before, I want to put some actual pressure on an inactive, and one lonely vote isn't going to cut it.

##Unvote: Kou
##Vote: Hanako

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

I think I sort of covered this in the rest of my post, but the reason is because Mitsuo is at least active. Even if I don't have the evidence I need right now to prove he's scum, I might be able to if I keep him around for a while longer, or he might find a way to prove that he's town.
Hanako, however hasn't said anything. I have no way of getting evidence of her being a scum, because she doesn't post. The last thing we need right now is less activity. And, I find her silence to be a bigger threat right now, especially because Igor doesn't seem to be looking for a replacement, (unless I missed something in the discussion thread), though maybe I'm reading too far into that.

Note: Sorry it took me so long to get this short post out. I'm trying to multitask and it isn't going well.

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

I too want to do this, even if we end up getting a townie, I would rather kill an inactive townie than an active townie.

#vote: Hanako

no this is not bandwagoning, it was my idea in the first place