P4 - Mafia XIX Game Thread - [Game Over] Mafia DOMINATION

[[M] Mom – Host]

Ho ho. Trying to doublevote, are we? Good eye you have. I almost had that slipped away from me.

[[M] Elize]

What is there to talk about, both Daidara and I have quoted why Souji appears suspicious and his odd mannerism, whereas Hanako just hasn't posted since Day 1, and a few people want to vote off in-actives. Though it is curious that the person who voted for her originally decided to unvote her the last minute.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Votecount, btw.

[M] Souji (4) - [M] Naoto, [M] Kashiwagi, [M] Kanji, [M] Daidara
[M] Hanako (4) - [M] Namatame, [M] Mitsuo, [M] Nanako, [M] Adachi
[M] Rise (1) - [M] Souji
[M] Naoto (0) -
[M] Daidara (0) -
[M] Kou - (0) -
[M] Mitsuo (0) -
[M] Kanji (0) -

[[M] Athena]

One of the mafia is bound to be one of the inactives. Which one, I don't know. Hanako has done absolutely nothing to help the town. For all intents and purposes, she is anti-town and so lynching her isn't "a bad thing".

However we still don't gain much from it. But I'm more willing to off her than Souji for this reason: if Souji is scum, we will find more evidence to support it. Hanako has given us nothing, will give us nothing, and is probably trying to smurf us all over dawgs.

[[M] Athena]

Forgive me for asking Igor, but are we having self-votes for non-voters? Your vote count doesn't appear to, but I thought I'd check.

[[M] Elize]

Personally, I feel that if the mafia's tactic was simply to not show up until the night phase to play, they they are not really playing by the rules and would hope that Igor would expel them from the game cause that is sort of a cheap tactic to win. The fact that this hasn't really occurred tells me, that they have been active and simply hiding in plane sight.

[[M] Caprica]

We already made two mistakes with our lynches. I would much rather go after someone with a reason then a blind shot.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Forgive me for asking Igor, but are we having self-votes for non-voters? Your vote count doesn't appear to, but I thought I'd check.

Oh, that would appear so. Wouldn't that give Hanako a self-vote then?

[[M] Aaron]

As far as I know, there's no penalty for being silent in this game. I once hosted a game like that and the mafia chose to off all of the active posters and remain silent themselves. I thought to myself hey, everyone can play how they want, it's not my fault if the town decides to take the opportunity to kill themselves! They totally crushed the town, but they were so bored with it that they requested the penalty never be removed again. So I do think inactives are something to consider

[[M] Aaron]

Oh, nevermind!

[[M] Elize]

How utterly childish in a mystery.

[[M] Athena]

It would, which makes it pretty important xD

[[M] Caprica]

I still say we are making another mistake

[[M] Athena]

I have to go, right now, which is a pain in the ass dudebros and brochicks. But I'm not getting too much in the way of scum vibes from Souji so Hanako is my best pick. Good luck

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

I'm sticking with Souji, he's just been way too suspicious, and Hanako is probably getting replaced. Sure you can say that if Souji really is scum, we can give him more time to act that way, but if Hanako really is inactive, can't you give them the opportunity to be replaced?