Looking at the table, I think what's happened here is that Newcastle are overachieving somewhat this season and (SPOILER)Everton are only above Liverpool by virtue of two quick wins over West Brom and the Swans, and that'll soon equal itself out. Then above that, you've got Chelsea, Tottenham, Arsenal and Man City/Utd. The fact is, those five teams are just better teams than Liverpool at the moment.
If you ignore Newcastle and (SPOILER)Everton for now, the next team up is Chelsea and you just have to compare their squads. Chelsea have proven scorers in Drogba, Sturridge et al (we'll forget Torres), as well as a top class midfield with Mata, Essien, Meireles and so on. Put that side by side with Liverpool's grossly unintimidating lineup of Andy Carroll, Charlie Adam and Jordan Henderson and I can't really place Liverpool above them in the table. They have two players who are truly world class in Suarez and Kuyt, but other than that it's just a merry-go-round of average players with the exception of pensioner Steven Gerrard.
From this we can deduce that they are probably on paper the sixth best team in the league, and are two places away from it because of bad form, good form from the two teams above them, and I'm sure Suarez's eight game ban didn't help much. (SPOILER)Actually this one is just a joke. Carry on. You guys just need to step back and reassess your goals before any tribal chief killing.