Mafia XXI: History Edition Sign and Discussion Thread

[Agent Proto]

I wish Joan hadn't died last night. I tried.

[Freya]

Post flavor I want to see what happened!

[[M] Mom – Host]

Well played, Mafia. You smurfed up the balance of my game. :/

In all seriousness, a no damage run Mafia team. I bet that's never happened before!

[Freya]

Wait so kaiser and Jentleness both had two accounts? that's kinda.... really lame.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Wait...what? No, Jentleness had only one account. Did I make a mistake? *Checks*

[Hollycat]

it kind of is.

This was hilarious, I havent ever seen a game this short before.

[Freya]

You made several xD Didn't shattered dreamer replace and blah blah

I don't get the two accounts thing. And one that's a cop.

[Psychotic]

I'll be honest, I was genuinely in a moral quandary with Elizabeth/Simon. I had seen this thing before in Mafia III - the last time I got to be mafia in a main game. Yes, it has been that long. Slowpoke hacked other accounts and did the same spelling mistakes between them, all while voting for me with absolutely no way of knowing I was scum. I thought it was groundhog day. I was not amused

I originally thought Elizabeth was a cop and investigated me until Simon showed up and started speaking for her and using the same exact reasons to lynch me. I saw KaiserDragon post as Simon (and delete the posts afterwards) and I didn't think he'd hack an account. So the only conclusion was that he had some new EoFF member on his team (cult/second set of masons) and he was leading them in the posts. But I will admit the idea of him hacking someone did not totally go away - sorry KD for thinking that, but like I say, been through it before - and I was really concerned about it. I was going to PM the mods and ask them to get a CK who was not playing to investigate, but then I didn't want them to give a role away to me by saying "don't worry, bitch be cool" I decided just to declare war on him and hope for the best.

[Freya]

I stand by the point we made earlier about how talking is not a mafia tactic. The reason we walked all over you lot was because none of you talked. I would have acted almost exactly the same as I did had I been town. Pointing out who is suspicious is not a mafia tactic. It allows others to understand and agree/disagree with what you say. So when KD had that "pointing fingers" logic against us, I wanted to throw things at him. But we got him in the end

Really, no one had much reason for any of the lynches. But that's cause none of you discussed it. No one really brought up anything. The way I had poked at Hypo was more productive than anything. Yes he outed himself as a miller but it got the thread and town somewhere. When you poke and prod is when people slip up. Offense is the best defense imo.

[Psychotic]

Speaking of things that people accused us of being scummy for despite it not being scummy. My favourite tactic, regardless of alignment, is to be incredibly snide and abusive to anybody who accuses or votes for me, and to try to pour suspicion onto them. In fact I think I am much, much worse with this when I am town so I was amused to be accused of being scummy for this too. As a townie, I don't like being accused as I have to play defense rather than offence, so I will work you over to discredit you and put off anybody else who will consider accusing me. It helps the town... very slightly... which is how I justify it, but it's also damned fun.

[Jentleness]

I can't believe Jesus made a mistake! I only played Genghis Khan. First time as Mafia, but I didn't play any different than I would have played as a Townie, with the exception that I used logic to throw people off the scent of the Mafia than to pin point them. I found it amusing how easy it was to diffuse the situation between Catherine and Shaka and get everyone to vote Saladin!

[Carl the Llama]

I'll be honest, I was genuinely in a moral quandary with Elizabeth/Simon. I had seen this thing before in Mafia III - the last time I got to be mafia in a main game. Yes, it has been that long. Slowpoke hacked other accounts and did the same spelling mistakes between them, all while voting for me with absolutely no way of knowing I was scum. I thought it was groundhog day. I was not amused

I originally thought Elizabeth was a cop and investigated me until Simon showed up and started speaking for her and using the same exact reasons to lynch me. I saw KaiserDragon post as Simon (and delete the posts afterwards) and I didn't think he'd hack an account. So the only conclusion was that he had some new EoFF member on his team (cult/second set of masons) and he was leading them in the posts. But I will admit the idea of him hacking someone did not totally go away - sorry KD for thinking that, but like I say, been through it before - and I was really concerned about it. I was going to PM the mods and ask them to get a CK who was not playing to investigate, but then I didn't want them to give a role away to me by saying "don't worry, bitch be cool" I decided just to declare war on him and hope for the best.

I had a feeling someone would have seen me post that, as to why I was so sure you were scum (which I was dead on about) was because you kept pointing fingers at everyone, call it gut instinct, plus I watch alot of Poirot xD and I can usually figure out who the killer is just based on gut feeling, if however I went into the game and said "Cat is scum, why? cause of my gut feeling" they would have laughed me out of there and beat me to death with a barge pole or something, as for who I investigated, I had no idea about the whole insane cop thing (see Bolivar's post about why a cop would investigate themselves) so on the first night I investigated Hannibal, then you guys killed him the next day, you were smart in provoking my suspicions at Gandhi () so the following night I investigated him, my reason for not posting on Lizzy much was cause I wanted to not be lynched, I could have used Bolivar as a meat shield (incase he invoked the wrath of the Mafians) and have him do all the pointing and arguing and seeing how you reacted on the 4th it was probably a wise move, then once Lance got lynched and flipped cop I was like... am I paranoid/naive? so I investigated myself on the THIRD night, if I was a more experienced player, you might have been successful in framing me on night 1 *cough* I would have been pissed at being given 2 opposing faction people >.>

With me been given 2 roles, when I signed up (as ????) I told Laddy that I had given Dak 2 roles last time and if he felt like he needed more people I would be happy to fill out 2 roles.

As for my having to stop playing the game... work has been a bitch recently one of my managers left and now I find myself working every day of the week and feeling dead tired at the end of the day, to tired to contemplate playing Mafia.

[Freya]

We didn't kill you before day 4 because we used you KD xD We only need to convince one person to vote day four and the way you acted, baseless votes for us and misconstrued info, you were a perfect target. We just need someone to agree and bam you would be out.

To be honest, I really wanted to get Shaka Lynched. That wasn't a tactic xD Props should go to Justy though. Those masons, poor masons.

[Yar]

You can't put me and Kaycee on the same team. We have an unfair advantage against everyone else because we're so in-sync with each other. xD

To my mason buddies: I'm sorry I deceived you! D: I felt really bad about it, but I wanted to win.

[Jiro]

That's what I call a white wash. Bugger. I mean I don't even know what happened I was unconscious for most of it but that's not the result I wanted!