I was pretty convinced I was going to come into this thread and slag off either VIII or X, but having thought on and read some posts, I think I might plump for II. I didn't really enjoy the game much at all, whereas I definitely did with VIII and X. I can appreciate the game for what it tried to do and how it tried to innovate and likewise that its story and characters weren't bad for such an early game. Having said that, I just wasn't a fan of the game and have never felt the urge to play it again.