Originally Posted by
edczxcvbnm
I like Problem Sleuth and greatly dislike Homestruck. I was reading Problem Sleuth before Homestruck began and I quickly abandoned Homstruck after just a little while. The thing I liked about Problem Sleuth was the reader driven aspect of it. At the end that fell off but almost all of the best stuff comes early on in the story when the readers were making people do stupid things that resulted in hilarity.
With Homestruck it was clear this wasn't going to be the case and that animations and eventually game...ish-play, music and messaging text dumps would be heavily incorporated into the story and style while he practically will entirely created the narrative. I was not a fan and it is 3 years later and this story is still going on. I thought Problem Sleuth was too long with something like 2000 images but this one must be at 6000 or something by now.