Heroes & Villians Mafia XXII Game Thread: Day 3

[Hollycat]

Wolverine (0)-
Batman (0)-
Iron man (2)- batman, Wonder Woman
captain america (1)- wolverine
Thor (2)- spiderman, thor

I changed my mind. You have a maximum of 1 hour ten minutes.

Things have got a bit nuts with my sister's 18th birthday party being set up for tomorrow so HC you're going to have to do the flavour for the lynch

I have it. Can you PM the list of who is playing who so I don't leave a blank?

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

All roles & players were assigned randomly & I'm honestly a little offended by assertions to the contrary.

TBH I seriously don't know why you would be offended by this, each to their own I guess.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Well I tried my best, sorry I couldn't change anyones mind but to be perfectly honest I still think Batman is a jester... congrats to you if you arn't, a clever game you have played.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

I'm not a jester, I'm a sprinklefairy.

Spiderman, how do you rate your own mafia playing abilities? Do you think you have some good quality experience and that you can provide some really good insight?

[Hollycat]

Since there is a tie, the day will continue for 51 minutes. At that point, if none has more votes than anyone else, then Iron Man will be Lynched. If you make the conversation interesting enough, I am willing to extend this time limit up to 5 hours from now.

Remember, I will be check vote counts at the hour mark, so a single vote in between that ends up being a tie later will not change the result.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

I'm not a jester, I'm a sprinklefairy.

Spiderman, how do you rate your own mafia playing abilities? Do you think you have some good quality experience and that you can provide some really good insight?

Well... my game play experience isn't massive, but I have always been suspicious of the right people, but never been articulate enough to put my suspicions into words, in other words, I get a gut feeling about people, then tend to die quickly but continue to watch the game and my suspicions tend (and not trying to be big headed here but by tend I mean 9/10 times) to be right.

[Shattered Dreamer]

All roles & players were assigned randomly & I'm honestly a little offended by assertions to the contrary.

TBH I seriously don't know why you would be offended by this, each to their own I guess.

I guess offended is the wrong word. Why would I hand pick who gets what role? If you've played a few games of Mafia here at EoFF who begin to see some players are a lot better than others so purposely assigning certain people power roles could ruin a game before it starts. Like Batman said anyone who hosts that way shouldnt host

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

So you think you're pretty good and make good arguments.

And you think the hosts picked mafia out of the good players.

Perhaps you are mafia and you think you got given the role of mafia because you are good at the game.

How would you respond to that?

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

To be perfectly frank I think Thor is most likely to be Mafia, or siblings with Loki (who as I said has only posted twice since the game began) why don't you give me your thoughts on that Bats?

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

I'm a little confused Spiderman, do you believe that Batman and Thor are in cahoots with each other, or do think that Batman is a Jester? I'm willing to listen to your arguments but right now you seem to be contradicting yourself.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

I don't think Thor is mafia.

Loki is disturbingly quiet at the moment. He was more active yesterday. The same is true a lot of people though, and I wish more people would post because it's impossible to tell if it's an evasion tactic or if they're busy or don't give a trout.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

So you think you're pretty good and make good arguments.

And you think the hosts picked mafia out of the good players.

Perhaps you are mafia and you think you got given the role of mafia because you are good at the game.

How would you respond to that?

Well thats fair tbh, you have your thoughts and welcome to try and glean some information from my posts or to try and twist my words around, but then your saying that (if you believe what you said to be true) you think shattered dreamer is being untruthful when he said all roles are randomly assigned, I know I am not Mafia, but I don't know who is so its only fair to be suspicious of all people who are playing this game.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

I do not think Shattered Dreamer is being untruthful. Let me explain again: This is not about the truth of how the roles were actually assigned, this is about your viewpoint on how the roles were assigned.

I know that, before he clarified, you held the following two views:

- The roles were not randomly assigned
- The mafia roles were assigned to good players

You also admitted an additional view:

- You are a good player.

I am not trying to twist words or be suspicious of you. I was just interested to see your thoughts.

[Hollycat]

STOP TALKING ABOUT WHAT THE MODS DID.

you are supposed to be in a town, supposedly with no internet or something. please get back to the game.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

I'm a little confused Spiderman, do you believe that Batman and Thor are in cahoots with each other, or do think that Batman is a Jester? I'm willing to listen to your arguments but right now you seem to be contradicting yourself.

What I think is that Batman is a jester, why? Because of all the reasons I have posted: he calls attention to himself by doing that ##daykill: Thor prank, prank = prankster = jester? and he then went on to say "I wanted the attention" and also votes for himself (another prank).

Thor I believe to be Mafia because as Captain America so eloquently pointed out:

I beg to differ, old bean.

Good luck town. you have a huge problem with one of your people xD

Pretty simple really.