Of course people can act suspiciously on Day 1. People get assigned their roles before the game starts, not on Night 1. The mafia tend to be more cautious about accusations, getting attention onto themselves and contributing anything that can be traced back to them. It's basic psychology. We all do it when we're mafia. If you pick up those subtle cues, put a little bit of pressure on someone, you can start to see patterns forming. (Which is what I am doing right now!)

Don't make me do the "Yes but in Mafia 48272, Joe caught a mafia on day 1!" business because so help me god I will. And nobody wants that.

To say nothing on day 1 - a day where you have acted in a suspicious manner - can be held against anyone speaks for itself my friend.

Incidentally, Iron Man, since I voted for you you've:


  • Accused me of being new
  • Accused me of freaking out
  • Accused me of being a nuisance


Given that none of this is remotely true, I would appreciate it if you stopped trying to deflect things, and give up on your ad hominem strategy.

Trying to criticise me personally is not going to give you any reward. I've made some good points against you - including this post - and they're not just going to go away.