Everyone apart from you apparently, Wonder Woman! Brucie and Iron Man seem to be quite enjoying accusing each other of being new and according to Wolverine being a new player is codeword for an assumption of something that is impossible to discern from his post because it makes no sense at all! From what I have gathered over the last couple of pages of this thread:

-Being a new player, or CLAIMING to be a new player means you are either trying to do something to prevent getting a vote, or are a mafia in disguise, or you are accusing someone else of being one
-The amount of posts you make directly correlates to your likelihood of being a mafia member
-Galactus is fond of military men on incredible amounts of steroids

So I think there are a couple of valid reasons that it matters whose first time playing it is or not! And the post counts! According to Iron Man this kind of thing is the way you can tell the scum from the townies and that what has been said or not said or whatever hidden clues Brucie is going on about that he has mysteriously seen but not divulged are actually not important. IS THIS CORRECT? PLEASE HELP ME