Preferrably RIGHT NOW, but later is also OK.
Make your pick:
Resident Evil 5: Professional mode (I'm missing 5 or so levels)
Little Big Planet (collecting secrets n stuff)
Little Big Planet 2 (collecting secrets n stuff)
I'm not opposed to downloading a game from PSN either, so if you have any suggestions, hit me with 'em! I don't play most FPS, Racing or Sports, but I'm up for anything adventurish or action-y. I'm a devil at platforming as well.
Here's a list of Co-op games on the PSN anyhow
Maybe the Resident Evil Chronicles series or something? Could be fun. I don't have Playstation Move, but might work out OK with the regular controller.