Here's how I put them

Story:
KH2
KH1
BBS
chain of memories
358
coded

gameplay:
BBS
KH2
Coded
358
chain of memories
KH

Looks:
BBS
KH2
358
KH
chain of memories
coded

music:
KH2
BBS
All the others

replay-ability:
BBS
KH2
KH
Chain of memories
358
coded


My overall score:
BBS
KH2
358
KH
Chain of memories
the manga
Coded.