KIRK OR PICARD SUPERDEATH BATTLE 2000 AHHHHH

[Pike]

The banter between Kirk, Bones, and Spock

This is one of the best things about Star Trek ever.

Edit: Adding that I do agree that TNG was the best Star Trek, with DS9 very close behind, but it's hard for me to say much bad about TOS because the movies, especially, did so many things right.

[The Man]

Kirk, Bones, and Spock are a pretty archetypal Freudian trio, and the execution was superb both in the original series and in the new film.

Nothing beats Picard, though. I'd probably agree with the ranking of TNG > DS9 > TOS > other Star Trek.

[Laddy]

The banter between Kirk, Bones, and Spock

This is one of the best things about Star Trek ever.

Edit: Adding that I do agree that TNG was the best Star Trek, with DS9 very close behind, but it's hard for me to say much bad about TOS because the movies, especially, did so many things right.

I actually like Voyager the most after TNG, and would say Janeway is the best captain after Picard.

[Madame Adequate]

NOPE

NOPE

LADDY THIS IS WORSE THAN IF YOUR FREAKOUT HAD BEEN REAL

BEST BE TROLLIN' SON

What deranged mind can consider Janeway better than Kirk or Sisko or even Archer?

TNG > DS9 > TOS > Enterprise > No Star Trek ever again > VOY

[Laddy]

NOPE

NOPE

LADDY THIS IS WORSE THAN IF YOUR FREAKOUT HAD BEEN REAL

BEST BE TROLLIN' SON

What deranged mind can consider Janeway better than Kirk or Sisko or even Archer?

TNG > DS9 > TOS > Enterprise > No Star Trek ever again > VOY

YOU ARE DERANGED

KATHRYN JANEWAY IS GOD

DONT CALL ME DERANGED

VOYAGER > EVERYTHING!!!!!!!<nf<nfns<jfndjfn<dsfdnf< youarederanged!="" kathryn="" janeway="" is="" god!<="" html=""></nf<nfns<jfndjfn<dsfdnf<>

[Madame Adequate]

Now you're just trolling.

[Laddy]

(SPOILER)

That's not against the rules per se but something like that should blatantly be behind spoiler tags. ~MILFY

[Hollycat]

And we've hit 23-0. Proof Piard is better in any and all universi.

[Raistlin]

Voyager is at least better than Enterprise. I agree that it's worse than TNG and DS9. TOS is 3rd just because of the Kirk-Spock-Bones dynamic and it had George Takei going nuts with a sword.

[Araciel]

Enterprise is to Star Trek what the prequel trilogy is to Star Wars

AKA should have been aborted.

[charliepanayi]

Scott Bakula deserved better than Enterprise

[Slothy]

Voyager is at least better than Enterprise.

I'm honestly not so sure since it's been so long since I watched Enterprise. I think I may actually hate Voyager a bit more. Yeah, Enterprise was bad, and Scott Bakula certainly did deserve to be on a better Star Trek (but we'll always have Quantum Leap), but at least it didn't start out with a cool premise and by the second episode completely abandon it. Or fill the show with as many terrible alien villains with half assed nose prosthetics as it could. Or try to drown people in even more unintelligible techno babble than usual to distract us from the fact that they're hand waving their way out of a problem again. Plus it didn't make a complete mockery of legitimately cool villains like the Borg.

Oh, and Enterprise didn't last for 7 years.

The only upside to Voyager was the Doctor, and the episodes with Reginald Barclay. Though sometimes even the Doctor got episodes that amounted to bad rehashes of excellent episodes from other series, particularly the episode that basically ripped off the trial of Data, but had him fighting for the rights to control his holo-novel. Except having rights to you work isn't nearly as interesting as potentially being a slave and forced to partcipate in dangerous experiments. And they waffled on the conclusion.

Have I mentioned I hate Voyager?

[charliepanayi]

I agree about the Doctor being the best thing about Voyager by a country mile (Picardo is just brilliant in general), though I liked that episode with the book he wrote, if only for the funny portrayals of the other characters in his book.

[Raistlin]

The only upside to Voyager was the Doctor, and the episodes with Reginald Barclay. Though sometimes even the Doctor got episodes that amounted to bad rehashes of excellent episodes from other series, particularly the episode that basically ripped off the trial of Data, but had him fighting for the rights to control his holo-novel. Except having rights to you work isn't nearly as interesting as potentially being a slave and forced to partcipate in dangerous experiments. And they waffled on the conclusion.

I must concede here that I have no watched all of Voyager, and specifically not that episode. Which is good, because that was one of my favorite TNG episodes and I would not want to see it butchered.