The Justice League and the Avengers get into a fight

[Mirage]

Is kryptonite banned?

If no, whichever team superman is on, cause he's just stupidly overpowered.

[NeoCracker]

I dont' think Thor could beat Superman.

No one, however, can beat Hulk. (Well, depending. If we look at the Hulk from the new movies, he comes across as
having a limit to how strong he can get. Comic Hulk seems pretty damn unlimited.)

Of course if we are looking at current movies vs. eachother, it's a hard call as I've not seen the newest superman movie, and my knowledge is limited to the original few.

In which case I give the fight to Thor.

I read a book a long time ago about the hulk based in the facts in the comics, and if I'm remembering correctly, he has always had a limit, and I think it was like 20 tons or something of force, he was definitely listed as weaker and lighter than abomination. I don't like DC, (except batman) but superman would definitely win here. Take out him and Iron man and you would definitely have a much more even fight. Now, if you want to keep Superman in and make it pretty even, take out CA, and add in Gilgamesh or Quasar.
Gilgamesh is immortal and stronger than the hulk, and Quasar is basically halfway between superman and green lantern

The premise of 'facts' is hard to judge due to the radical differences from writer to writer.

For example, we've had Deathstroke defeat a group of 5 JLA members, including Green Lantern, in fight in which he had no prep time.

He was later beaten in a one on one fight with Green Arrow.

[Goldenboko]

Moral of this thread: Superman is OP.

[Hollycat]

I dont' think Thor could beat Superman.

No one, however, can beat Hulk. (Well, depending. If we look at the Hulk from the new movies, he comes across as
having a limit to how strong he can get. Comic Hulk seems pretty damn unlimited.)

Of course if we are looking at current movies vs. eachother, it's a hard call as I've not seen the newest superman movie, and my knowledge is limited to the original few.

In which case I give the fight to Thor.

I read a book a long time ago about the hulk based in the facts in the comics, and if I'm remembering correctly, he has always had a limit, and I think it was like 20 tons or something of force, he was definitely listed as weaker and lighter than abomination. I don't like DC, (except batman) but superman would definitely win here. Take out him and Iron man and you would definitely have a much more even fight. Now, if you want to keep Superman in and make it pretty even, take out CA, and add in Gilgamesh or Quasar.
Gilgamesh is immortal and stronger than the hulk, and Quasar is basically halfway between superman and green lantern

The premise of 'facts' is hard to judge due to the radical differences from writer to writer.

For example, we've had Deathstroke defeat a group of 5 JLA members, including Green Lantern, in fight in which he had no prep time.

He was later beaten in a one on one fight with Green Arrow.

Really? Geeze.
Now that you mention it, there are like twenty versions of each of the heroes aren't there? And they all have different strengths and limits.


Anyone have a link to the planet destroying hulk? I haven't seen that one before.

[NorthernChaosGod]

I dont' think Thor could beat Superman.

No one, however, can beat Hulk. (Well, depending. If we look at the Hulk from the new movies, he comes across as
having a limit to how strong he can get. Comic Hulk seems pretty damn unlimited.)

Of course if we are looking at current movies vs. eachother, it's a hard call as I've not seen the newest superman movie, and my knowledge is limited to the original few.

In which case I give the fight to Thor.

I read a book a long time ago about the hulk based in the facts in the comics, and if I'm remembering correctly, he has always had a limit, and I think it was like 20 tons or something of force, he was definitely listed as weaker and lighter than abomination. I don't like DC, (except batman) but superman would definitely win here. Take out him and Iron man and you would definitely have a much more even fight. Now, if you want to keep Superman in and make it pretty even, take out CA, and add in Gilgamesh or Quasar.
Gilgamesh is immortal and stronger than the hulk, and Quasar is basically halfway between superman and green lantern

The premise of 'facts' is hard to judge due to the radical differences from writer to writer.

For example, we've had Deathstroke defeat a group of 5 JLA members, including Green Lantern, in fight in which he had no prep time.

He was later beaten in a one on one fight with Green Arrow.

Really? Geeze.
Now that you mention it, there are like twenty versions of each of the heroes aren't there? And they all have different strengths and limits.


Anyone have a link to the planet destroying hulk? I haven't seen that one before.

I don't know exactly what everyone may be referring to, but in this storyline he kicks the trout out of a whole bunch of people.
World War Hulk - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[Mercen-X]

Mentioned: Versions of Hulk strong enough to destroy whole planets.
Not Mentioned: Versions of Superman that are immune to Kryptonite and do not require the yellow sun to function at superhuman capacity.

That's just smurfing cheating. He's already the most overpowered superhero in existence.

Pot : Kettle

Basically, the other members of Team Justice and Team Avenge will all be dead and Superman and Hulk will be deadlocked. If Superman didn't have the sense to fly Hulk off-planet, they'd destroy Earth centuries before they managed to hurt one another.

[Pike]

Just Superman vs. Hulk would be a great fight.

[Hollycat]

Just Superman vs. Hulk would be a great fight.

Superman would just thow Hulk into space. Way too one sided. A much more even fight would be Quasar versus Superman. One is an unstoppable force, the other can create unmovable shields Can you say best physics phenomena ever?

[Mercen-X]

To make a fight between the Justice League and the Avengers more dynamic, we'd have to replace Superman and Hulk with other important members. Hulk on the Avengers is pretty much the main loner, he could be replaced with Wolverine. On the JL, Supes is pretty much the team leader, without him, we need another with the same ability to inspire and command, Wonder Woman technically could, but she's primarily depicted as a feminist which would make it difficult for her to inspire her three male comrades, but she's already on the team so that point's moot. Steel is pretty much the DC version of Iron Man and, having himself been inspired by Superman, it wouldn't be much of a stretch to supplant the man-in-blue-tights with the man-in-stainless-steel-armor.

[Del Murder]

I think in the first Marvel vs. DC series it was Superman vs. Hulk and Supes won. However, that book also had Batman defeat Captain America so who knows how that works.

[NeoCracker]

I think in the first Marvel vs. DC series it was Superman vs. Hulk and Supes won. However, that book also had Batman defeat Captain America so who knows how that works.

Captain American is the peak of Human ability.

Batman has beaten Bane.

[Mercen-X]

Bear in mind that in most depictions, Bane is an idiot.

[NeoCracker]

Bear in mind that in most depictions, Bane is an idiot.

Well fine, he beat the tactically apt Bane. Satisfied?

[NorthernChaosGod]

Mentioned: Versions of Hulk strong enough to destroy whole planets.
Not Mentioned: Versions of Superman that are immune to Kryptonite and do not require the yellow sun to function at superhuman capacity.

That's just smurfing cheating. He's already the most overpowered superhero in existence.

Pot : Kettle

Basically, the other members of Team Justice and Team Avenge will all be dead and Superman and Hulk will be deadlocked. If Superman didn't have the sense to fly Hulk off-planet, they'd destroy Earth centuries before they managed to hurt one another.

Hulk is just really, really strong.

[Flaming Ice]

X-Men win.