After four years of not having my 360 -- in short, my Mom gave my brother my 360 (as in, the one I bought myself) when I was away to college without asking, and I wasn't allowed to have it back for ages -- I recently got it back, now that my brother and I are both adults who could discuss the issue reasonably.

I have barely gamed for the past few years, aside from Dwarf Fortress and some Jamestown, so I am buzzing with excitement to have my bawks back. What should I play? I am behind several years, so I am finally going to finish... Mass Effect the first.