Well, voting is over, and I'm a little late posting the results of the votes, so here they are! I shall also reveal the members who submitted their pumpkins as well.

Pumpkin 1Sephex - 8.2
Pumpkin 2Faris - 6.5
Pumpkin 3Jiro - 6.0
Pumpkin 4Shlup - 5.0
Pumpkin 5Tifa's Boobs - 4.7
Pumpkin 6Cim - 5.3

Considering this is a small batch of pumpkins, the overall winner goes to pumpkin 1, with a rating of 8.2! It's also the best carved pumpkin! Pumpkin 1 belongs to Sephex! Best designed pumpkin via photo manipulation goes to pumpkin 3, with a rating of 6.0, It belongs to Jiro!

Congrats guys! And thanks for putting up with this failed attempt of a contest for Halloween! Perhaps next time will be better planned.