I don't know - I'm really torn as to whether to agree. I think there were things that I liked about SH:C more than the original (I think the gameplay was generally better, likewise for the music and graphics) but I think in terms of the story I preferred the original. Don't get me wrong, there's not a lot between them for my money. However, I think they're both good but in different ways and I'd probably rank them about level. Having said that, I really should replay SH:C at some point - especially given that I've had the Japan battle music stuck in my head for the past week and I've no idea why.