I completely agree! I didn't like Tidus as a character, but I think that Karifean is absolutely right.
Forsaken Lover, Yuna might have not agreed to Yunalesca's proposal, but as you could see Wakka and Lulu would. In the end, I think Yuna would have been coerced into it. Especially because if you notice, in the beginning of the game, Tidus asks why do it, if he keeps coming back? And Yuna says that it is worth it, because then people are able to sleep peacefully if only for a little while, so she would have ultimately done it, were it not for him and Rikku's perseverance into trying to stop the cycle.