Quote Originally Posted by [M] Yuffie View Post
Quote Originally Posted by [M] Quistis View Post
Which means they are no more likely of being mafia than town. In fact, they are more likely of being town since the majority of players are generally town-aligned. It's pretty much a crap shoot with low odds.
As is every vote. However, I'd rather play with people whose actions I can appropriately judge. With all due respect, I have faith in my abilities to call out bulltrout.
But you can't judge people when Person A voted on inactive Person B. What does it tell you? Nothing because B never said jack, you can't infer if B said something to make someone upset, and clearly B was never close to closing the investigation since he never did jack crap. Person A could be a great townie, great scum, and you'd never be able to draw any conclusions from B's death.
This is EXACTLY why inactives are lynched early. You have nothing to go on Day 1. Later on mafia can trip up and contradict themselves if they post, if they don't the can just lie low and dodge the bullet. It happens all the time.

I remember Auron from Mafia V said very little and had no suspicion on him, town got lucky he got shot.