Anniversary Mafia Game Thread - The Final Day

[[M] Adama]

Biggs did come up with some very odd theories about Noctis being Mafia Godfather which we all now know were not true. He also roleclaimed to try to get traction in an attempt to threaten Noctis. I find it a little odd that he would keep targetting one of the town's strongest assets and trying to encourage a lynch against him. I appreciate there may be a forum rivalry between Psychotic and Del Murder but what if that is just a cover up - an excuse? Would you really lynch a good player who is a bulletproof townie just to settle an admin score?

To be honest rivalries should mean nothing when your trying to help the bleeding town

[[M] D'Anna]

I actually thought Noctis was part of a rival scum faction trying to take out his competition. Mafia Godfather and SK are also sometimes bulletproof. Also I really wanted that showdown and I would have never killed my boy Noctis.

I did suspect Blank. Go read my posts. My vote flip flopped between Yuffie and Blank all day because I suspected them both pretty equally. I stuck with Yuffie for a while because I felt Noctis had Blank handled and it's kind of grueling to have us both gang up on someone. In the end my grilling of Yuffie convinced me to change at the end of the day.

Relm, my vote is on you mainly because you were one of the final votes for Yuffie and you have been playing under the radar. Also poop.

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

I was the second person to vote yuffie and I stayed on her all day, and I started going after her on day 2. I don't really get how I've been going under the radar either, I've been posting pretty much most of the time I've been on apart from during the clustersmurf on day 2 when I had no idea what was going on and couldn't be bothered to join in.

all that said, I have no riposte for "poop", so well played.

[[M] Adama]

Biggs, Balthier has also been flying under the radar, only stopping in mainly during day two. Balthier was dangerously close to getting lynched on that day, and now's he's been more quiet than he was; it seems to me like he is avoiding the board more.

[[M] D'Anna]

Biggs did come up with some very odd theories about Noctis being Mafia Godfather which we all now know were not true. He also roleclaimed to try to get traction in an attempt to threaten Noctis. I find it a little odd that he would keep targetting one of the town's strongest assets and trying to encourage a lynch against him. I appreciate there may be a forum rivalry between Psychotic and Del Murder but what if that is just a cover up - an excuse? Would you really lynch a good player who is a bulletproof townie just to settle an admin score?

To be honest rivalries should mean nothing when your trying to help the bleeding town

They mean everything! The point of this is to be entertained and we would have put on a good show. Up until Yuffie mentioning kevlar vests I was not convinced that Noctis wasn't a SK or Mafia Godfather going after the rival's SK or Godfather. Both roles are often night kill immune.

You should know by now that my MO involves flip flopping votes left and right. Keeps the mafia guessing. In the end if I didn't think Noctis was scum I wouldn't have voted for him.

[[M] D'Anna]

Biggs, Balthier has also been flying under the radar, only stopping in mainly during day two. Balthier was dangerously close to getting lynched on that day, and now's he's been more quiet than he was; it seems to me like he is avoiding the board more.

Very true, however, Balthier voted for Blank and I think that buys him another day. He's certainly a viable under the radar candidate.

As are you!

[[M] Adama]

Since when? Petty rivalries distract the town from concentrating on finding mafia. While I'm sure the town would have loved a good show, I'm pretty sure trying to win is probably top priority right?

Besides, we have Relm's lovely drawings for entertainment.

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

to further elaborate, there are 6 players still alive who have been here less than I have, although this will take me level with balthier, which leaves 5 players alive who have posted more than me, one of whom is Wakka and 90 of his posts have been "I'm going for dinner."

so yeah, you're full of it. well, that's what i'd like to say, but I've still got no come back for "poop", so.

[[M] Colette]

They mean everything! The point of this is to be entertained and we would have put on a good show. Up until Yuffie mentioning kevlar vests I was not convinced that Noctis wasn't a SK or Mafia Godfather going after the rival's SK or Godfather. Both roles are often night kill immune.

The point of this is to kill mafia. This does sound like a cover up to me. What would you have done after you lynched him and we found out he was town? Apologized for killing a valuable asset and asked for a free pass because he is your rival?

This doesn't sit right with me. Sorry, I know you are a good player and I feel uneasy accusing you. I just don't know.

[[M] Adama]

Biggs, Balthier has also been flying under the radar, only stopping in mainly during day two. Balthier was dangerously close to getting lynched on that day, and now's he's been more quiet than he was; it seems to me like he is avoiding the board more.

Very true, however, Balthier voted for Blank and I think that buys him another day. He's certainly a viable under the radar candidate.

As are you!

If anything, I'm flying more above the radar than I have previously, I never intended not to post anything for Days Two - Four, it just sort of happened due to life stuff.

I think someone said I posted roughly five times on Day One, no one can say I'm not posting today; I've been present for most of the day, sans the middle.

[[M] Colette]

LOL I do not know if you have seen the discussion thread but Psycho is going PSYCHO about us lynching Biggs.

I don't know. Biggs is scummy but I am finding it hard to see past Wedge. Is Psycho usually wrong about this sort of thing? Not really.

[[M] Adama]

Well this IS THE PSYCHO. Ordinarily, my chip implanted in the base of my spine would obey Psychotic without question, but Wedge's annoying reports are niggling me. It can't be coincidence that everyone has wound up dead from his reports. What he do, lace em with anthrax or something

[[M] D'Anna]

What happens when anyone lynches a town? You move on and try again. You also act like I would have had the power of 10 votes at my disposal. It would have taken more than just me to lynch him so I hope I wouldn't get the sole blame.

None of you know what this supposed 'showdown' would have been so stop assuming that I'm a scum by asking for it. Psychotic has unorthodox methods but he finds the mafia in the end. Who's to say this wouldn't have ended the same? Feel free to lynch me for my flip flopping and aggressive style, but please leave this stupid showdown alone because it is wasting time.

[[M] Adama]

I don't really care how this "showdown" would have ended up, the mere fact that there was going to be some form of "showdown" when really we should be working together to fight the mafia is at best disconcerting.

Still, I'll keep my vote on Wedge. While I am highly suspicious of you Biggs, Wedge is more of a concern for me.

[[M] Colette]

None of you know what this supposed 'showdown' would have been so stop assuming that I'm a scum by asking for it. Psychotic has unorthodox methods but he finds the mafia in the end. Who's to say this wouldn't have ended the same? Feel free to lynch me for my flip flopping and aggressive style, but please leave this stupid showdown alone because it is wasting time.

I disagree. I think the showdown you kept calling for is a key piece of evidence to your intentions. I am now concerned because you are trying to avoid discussion and deflect away from it.