This game will get me fired! Typing in word then will paste into thread!

Provided Penelo is telling the truth, and I don't know how far we can trust her, it seems to me that the Grifter is a reverse Framer, then. It would be an interesting role. But it would also does fill in a blank. It would make logical sense that the teams are:

Faris - Godfather
Setzer - Ninja (Specialist kill role)
Wakka - Framer (Cop action alterer)
???? (Support)

and

Blank - Godfather
Galuf - Poisoner (Specialist kill role)
Relm - Grifter (Cop action alterer)
Penelo - Prostitute (Support)

I would hazard a guess that our ???? (support) could well be a Doctor given all the night kills flying around. But I have no proof of this either way, just a guess. This would then mean that it is Penelo alone. The next question is:

Is it better to put the teams down to 1 each, or eliminate one altogether?

If we eliminate Penelo, we have the advantage of there only being one night kill. The next day would see us with 2 mafia, 3 town, provided all night kills went off. Faris would then be lynched, and presuming the night kill went off, we would have 1 mafia, 2 town the next day. If Leon does some awesome moves in the night, this improves our chances.

If we eliminate Faris, we will still have two night kills. I can't legislate for this as there is the distinct possibility that the mafia will try to kill each other. I imagine that the other mafia would not kill Penelo, as Penelo would take the noose for them the next day.

I do rather like Faris's proposal to kill Cid. No disrespect to Jiro, but this Cid situation is untenable, and if any townie were to die, I would have it be him. Imagine if you're stuck on the last day with someone else and Cid. You would have absolutely nothing to judge him on. I don't know if he'd be replaced - I am kind of eyeing up the possibility of replacing him myself should I be night killed, so I may just be harming myself here! - but even if he was, it would be ridiculous at this point. Faris, if you want to help the town (and helping the town achieves your goal of defeating the other mafia) then Cid is definitely the best target. If nothing else, from a mafia (the game, not the faction!) player's perspective, having Cid around would ruin the finale and I don't want to waste a lynch on him, so a mafia kill would help everyone I think.