Are you going to decide by popular vote? How about you tell us about yourself. But if I missed that thread I can only recommend earlier games because the newer ones feel to modern/unfantasy to me.

Though I write my own stories now and don't really purchase other games these days. I can get enough off reading a synopsis/review anyway. Sorry for the rant and this posts doesn't mean trying a game more/less is less valid.

It's up to you to do the research ahead of time about a game before deciding to like it.