Here's some food for discussion. Some guy compiled the "Top Ten" lists of like 55 different gaming magazines/websites and made a definitive list.
the list of the best video games.png
Pretty unsurprising list overall; I'm somewhat surprised to see Super Mario 64 and Goldeneye so high (SM64 was great but there were better platformers on the 64, and as much as I LOVE Goldeneye it really has not aged well, imo.)
I should also note that this list is biased toward older games because he's including lists that were made some time ago.
Your thoughts?
EDIT: same idea using a slightly different ranking system:
different rankings.png
EDIT EDIT: If you ctrl+F for Deus Ex it's only on one list. WTF. I mean I guess it's on the best list on the entire page, so that's a small victory, but.