Quote Originally Posted by Jinx View Post
Well, series 3 in general just needs to be forgotten.
No it doesn't! There were a few dire ones like Gridlock and 42, yes, but there were gems too. Blink was of course great, but I also liked the Dalek Evolution story and the Family of Blood. And the Master was divine in those three episodes, I don't even care - I loved comedy Master as opposed to SERIOUS BUSINESS HERE IS MY EVIL BEARD Master.

But nothing compares to Season 5. With the exception of the Silurian episodes which were meh, every single other one knocked it out of the park imho.

Credit where credit is due though, RTD did write some belters - The Waters of Mars remains one of my absolute favourites.
Quote Originally Posted by ToriJ View Post
Usually when I talk to a person that says they prefer RTD, the moment they begin to list their favorite episodes it's all episodes that were written by Moffat.
Seriously. Empty Child, Girl in the Fireplace, Blink and the Library were all the highlights of their respective seasons.