Vin Diesel: It could be that one of the three of us is lying, but I am reluctant to pursue that line of thinking. Personally, I have no suspicion on either you or Sylvester Stallone, and obviously would prefer not to die in order to prove my role.

If there were four members of the mafia present at the beginning, then the addition of four more townies would theoretically balance things better. At the very least, we know that the original members house at least one member of the mafia. Four town aligned roles could easily have been added with the idea that suspicion would automatically follow them due to perceived imbalance. Again, speculating on the Game Master's intent can easily lead us astray and none can be sure of it barring the man himself.

I feel a better strategy is to focus on the original cast members and who is the most likely to be mafia aligned there, but given the general support of the "mafia hidden in the new guys" theory, I'm afraid that it might be one of us - looking most like me at the moment - stepping up to the gallows this afternoon.