What do you look for in a game?

[Spuuky]

I'm sorry, but 'gameplay' is not a valid answer (I don't mean to pick on you in particular Pol). Obviously, you play the game. If you can't play it, it's not a game. It's almost like saying the thing you look for in a movie is 'plot'.

What types of gameplay elements do you guys who like 'gameplay' look for?

I think this is really bad sarcasm, but I'll respond seriously anyway. It's possible to enjoy a game without enjoying the gameplay of it (I nearly enjoyed Xenosaga: Episode 2 despite the gameplay being abjectly awful). You can derive fun from other things than gameplay, like the atmosphere, story, or aesthetic.

But it is pretty close to the line and would be better served with a deeper explanation, yes.