I'm voting based purely on books. Considering the existence of Tom, a book only character, it would be unfair to do otherwise, I feel. I only downvoted Faramir out of spite. He's always been one of my favourite characters. xD

++ Tom Bombadil
- Eowyn
- Sauron [Name change to Isildur, plz.]

5 - Bilbo
9 - Pippin
9 - Sam
7 - Merry
7 - Thorin
13 - Balin
15 - Gollum
9 - Gimli
9 - Aragorn
15 - Boromir
15 - Gandalf
2 - Eowyn
15 - Faramir
8 - Smaug
19 - Tom Bombadil