Having now played through them all, my grand current gen Fallout DLC rankings:

  1. Old World Blues
  2. Point Lookout
  3. The Pitt
  4. Broken Steel
  5. Honest Hearts
  6. Dead Money
  7. Lonesome Road
  8. Operation: Anchorage
  9. Mothership Zeta


Such a shame that the last DLCs for both games were probably the weakest. I just finished on Mothership Zeta and I liked the characters, but it was just one long god damn grind against aliens and the fun slowly wore off.

I think the only contentious one will be Dead Money. I was tempted to put it above Broken Steel or alternatively below Operation: Anchorage. In the end I just went for the middle ground.