I think we need some clarification for how Best Member is to be nominated considering Jinx's comments. Just based on the OP, it looks like you're only supposed to vote for one (as in BoB's usual format). There should probably be a general set of instructions in the OP anyway about voting and how the finalist list was compiled (which would have headed off HC's complaint).
Also... Cuch is banned. I thought banned members were disqualified? Not being bitchy, just confused! I promis!
Signature by rubah. I think.
i thought these were forum awards though, not ff14 awards???
i just think it's funny that two people who never post got more nominations than some other couples
Have accounts + have participated in EoFF's wider community = part of the community. Chatters have frequently been included without any involvement in the forums.
Same reason I have no problem with Cuch's mention - there weren't many rules listed in these Ciddies... pretty sure a fair few people took advantage. xD This is Award Princess' call.
Bow before the mighty Javoo!
I was wondering about the Cuch thing too...
I saw the thread I think he was banned in, but I'm not sure what is was, because whatever it was was edited pretty quick. It was a couple weeks ago.
It's a temporary ban? I can remove him if it is going to cause *beef*.
Also.
I got SO many nominations which received only one nomination, my rules for cutting down nominations which were my choice was like this.
Del Murder IIII
Psychotic IIIII
Loony BoB I
Pike IIIIII
Shlup IIIII
Raisin IIII
Aulayna II
Freya II
Shorty II
Pantz II
Dr Unne II
Locky IIIIIIIIIIII
In this round, Locky, Del, Shlup, Pike, Psychotic and Raisin(? ha) all got a tonne more noms than the others, and there was over 5 people in that category with significantly more. They make it. The twofers and onesers don't. This wasn't how all categories worked, as most had a LOT of onesers, and most of the twosers made it.
I will post this here too, because it's relevant. Let's not make a show of ourselves in regards to the FFXIV nominators.
Anyone who takes the time to Nominate will have their nominations counted. These are your awards? Then you need to nominate and make them your awards. (I know many of you did though , but this message is for anyone who didn't!) These guys want to get involved, and if they win, then hey - maybe they'll start posting a whole lot more. In fact, a lot of those FFXIV members, actually made up nominations for many of the regular members as well.
That doesn't make sense to me at all. Why not just be equal for all the members across the board?
Which part doesn't make sense?
Okay so what y'all are saying.. Is that each person who is listed in the noms got at least 3 people nomming them to begin with?
That's my only question.