Lost Odyssey was pretty well received I think. It wasn't amazing by any means, but had a lot of awesome stuff going for it. Tales of Vesperia I liked quite a bit from what I played. Mass Effect is pretty well received (yes, it got less RPG-y over time). Not every Xbox rpg was just okay. Unless you mean specifically from Square then that's different. Infinite Undiscovery, The Last Remnant, FF XIII....