Quote Originally Posted by Mr. Shauna View Post
What do you mean by refute suggestions? If a card that auron had is suggested Shion will PM a player that card.
That's what refuting means.

Alternitively if know those cards then we are closer to the culprit. I'm just considering that we are on turn 4 and its been 10 days.
Turn 4 is not much, the game normally plays with 6 players max and 21 cards, it's normal it takes longer.

Who's to say that his suggestion was all wrong, perhaps he geussed the location and weapon correct, but got the player wrong. A false accusation means nothing.
Yes, it does. It gives you one completely valid clause you can add to your deductions. Since it may not be obvious for everyone, the clause you can add is:
"At least one of the three cards suggested is not in the secret file."

Negative information IS information.

If I didn't think Proto lost on purpose (you can suggest and immediately follow up with an accusation if no one contested, there's no reason not to do it), I'd even work with the assumption he has neither of the three cards.

I think posting the cards from those who made false suggestions will speed up the game which will probably take several more weeks to complete at the pace we are going at.
Oh it will, any information given -- positive or negative -- will speed up the game. I'd say we are about halfway done now, the past weekend was particularly slow because of Easter, hopefully it'll speed up now.