I have never understood this dispute.


They are both completely different things- they are just set in space.


One is a about a space team in a ship- that cannot go in reverse, just keeps on trekin'. The other has a more novel book feeling to it, with a feeling of revenge, forgiveness and how hate can consume you- with a more the " about the chosen one " story plot.

Luke being the chosen one that becomes the destined hero, and pops who struggles to battle life's struggles and goes insane- using his talent's to become a feared and malicious villain, which is really just a puppet to his fears and hate and the Emperor.


It depends if you prefer a more novel like story or more of a road-trip in space.