Cake... or pie?

[Colonel Angus]

Well, you make cheesecakes in pie crust, with many of the same ingredients you would make a pie with... I mean, it's just like Key Lime pie, but with cream cheese instead of lime junk.

ALSO KEY LIME PIE IS THE SECOND BEST PIE. I get really excited about pie.

I have to think about that.

Anyway, you don't have to worry about shorty, eat all the sugar you want. She's not here to chastise you for it anyway.

[Skyblade]

Cheesecake! It's both!

[Miss Mae]

Polar bears can also like cake.

france-polar-bear-flocke-2010-12-9-11-31-40.png

But I am not a polar bear, so I chose pie.

[Sephex]

Cake! Some bitch named Peach down tha block made me sum for beating up some dinosaur, yo.

[leader of mortals]

I believe the correct question to ask is Cake or Death

[Bubba]

I am glad I live in a world where I don't have to make this choice.

It's like choosing between beer and whiskey.

[blackmage_nuke]

I think a cake has specific requirements to be a cake but a pie can be anything baked into a pie pastry so you could have a cake pie. I choose pie

[Jess]

Cake! One of my friends makes the most delicious cakes and she always makes me one for my birthday! Mmmmmm.

I know it's boring, but I freaking love a Victoria Sponge. Also, red velvet is yummy!

I am partial to a slice of pecan pie, though.

[Alive-Cat]

I hate cake, no cakes

[Shorty]

Well, you make cheesecakes in pie crust, with many of the same ingredients you would make a pie with... I mean, it's just like Key Lime pie, but with cream cheese instead of lime junk.

ALSO KEY LIME PIE IS THE SECOND BEST PIE. I get really excited about pie.

I have to think about that.

Anyway, you don't have to worry about shorty, eat all the sugar you want. She's not here to chastise you for it anyway.

COMMENCE CHASTISING THIS THREAD MAKES ME SO ANGRY AAAAAAUGH

For reals, though. All weekend I've just wanted to simultaneously shovel carrot cake and red velvet cake into my gaping maw and I can't.

[Carl the Llama]

Anyone who chooses cake over pie needs counseling.

I fixed this for you.





I believe these two videos accurately represent my feelings.

[Christmas]

[Loony BoB]

Pie wins, because pie can have meat in it and meat pies are just the best thing ever. Especially a good potato-top pie. Mmmmm. And then there are so many other options which, with the right person and the right ingredients, have far more potential than any cake. If you guys go to a great bakery somewhere in NZ or Aus you'll probably find some damned incredible pies there. The UK has alright ones when it comes to variety but they lack the extreme quality of a Southern Hemisphere meat'n'pastry.

Loco, if you're making your cheesecake in a pie pastry, you're doing it wrong. Biscuit base or nothin'.

[Shorty]

Graham cracker is the base for cheesecake, you fools.

[Loony BoB]

Some of you people wouldn't know a cheesecake if it hit you in the face.

EDIT: Wait unless by cracker you mean biscuit.