Silent Hill 2 is my favorite, but I can also enjoy anything with space and horror. Space terrifies me. The vastness, the mystery, the darkness, the asteroids, the Sandra Bullock. It's scary. I believe the games I've played that involve this are Enemy Zero, 7 Days a Skeptic, and Doom. Quake kind of scared me too even though it wasn't really meant to be scary. I haven't played Dead Space. It's a giant batch of nope.
Fun fact: I never got to finish playing SH1 when it came out because my brother hid it after he crapped his pants. I still have no idea where that game is, but I did manage to find Sega Saturn version of Resident Evil.
Anyway check this out: http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/01/...ack-on-in-2014