I liked The Eye. It has a few moments that should get to you if you let it.

Was rather disappointed with The Crazies.

The original [REC] is worth watching, but tbh it disappointed me in the end, too. One of those horror movies that starts off well but then just doesn't know where to go with itself once it's gone through the reveal. Also "found footage" just annoys me. Way past tired of it.

If you like psychological non-supernatural horror, then Wolf Creek is pretty good. The main character is evil as smurf.

If atmosphere/darkness is what gets you, The Descent wasn't terrible. Very claustrophobic. So if darkness and tight spaces make you sweat, it might be something to try. Outside that, it's not the greatest movie, though, so look elsewhere if you can be in tight places without panicking.