The Arkham games are fun for a single play through or so, but the fact that they're so on the rails and quite repetitive wears thin. Especially when they're so damn easy.

Spider-Man 2 and Ultimate Spider-Man are the best adaptations as far as capturing what it would be like to be that hero with their powers. X-Men Legends and Legends 2 are also quite enjoyable what with the variety of characters and powers.