I never said you said they were bad Just throwing it out there to aid our discussion.
I guess. For the record, I tend to love certain tropes.

I was just saying that the P4 cast is just as trope-ish as most JRPG casts. The difference is that it uses tropes which are rarely seen in JRPGs.

Not sure if I made it clear, but I'm not trying to put the P4 cast down either. I love those guys and gals. One of my favorite RPGs ever. I probably only prefer 1 game to it(my list changes a lot though, lol).